"On Death Row" Conversation with James Barnes
***/****
directed by Werner Herzog
"On Death Row" Portrait of Robert Fratta
**/****
directed by Werner Herzog
by Walter Chaw Two
shot-for-television documentaries, running about 50 minutes apiece, serve as
Werner Herzog's epilogue to 2011's Into the Abyss, each profiling a
single inmate in the inimitable Herzog style that has evolved over the years into something that doesn't punish its subjects (as it once did) so
much as it punishes the audience. Looking back to the way he shot coroner Franc G.
Fallico in Grizzly Man, allowing him to twist a few beats
too long, reveals that Fallico was perhaps a little too eager for the camera. That
strategy–delightful then–is a bludgeon now, as the extra beats have become
interminable and, I'm afraid, useless. Of the two docs screened at this year's
Telluride Film Festival, the first, "Conversation with James Barnes", is
the better, as Herzog gives time to one of Barnes's cousins, who declares The
Exorcist to be a documentary because, among other things, anyone who twisted her head around like Linda Blair does in that movie would have died. No,
it's true, the logic doesn't work. It's less Herzog finding the
equivalent of his bingo-playing chicken in these inbred huckleberries than it is Herzog getting the money shot by telling the poor, dumb thing that no,
he's never seen The Exorcist. It's brilliant. And it's cruel. "Portrait
of Robert Fratta", on the other hand, profiles narcissistic Death Row
pretty boy Fratta in a way that reveals almost nothing except what it looks
like when Herzog riffs too long on the same theme. In the post-film Q&A,
moderated by an obsequious Ken Burns, Herzog promised that he's done now with
these Death Row interviews–it's almost like he understands that he might have
picked at this one 'til it bled, and his consistent disclaimer that he wants to
humanize these interview subjects because, as a German, he's seen the evil of capital
punishment carried out by a monolithic State, has become brittle and, fatally,
ironic.
