Search Film Freak Central Web search

powered by FreeFind

A Film Freak Central DVD Review by Bill Chambers


TEARS OF THE SUN (2003)
* (out of four)

Join "Film Freak Central"'s mailing list
(receive update alerts Thursdays bi-weekly)
Enter your name and email address:
Name:
Email:
Subscribe Unsubscribe

starring Bruce Willis, Monica Bellucci, Cole Hauser, Fionnula Flanagan
screenplay by Alex Lasker & Patrick Cirillo
directed by Antoine Fuqua

The Film
excerpted from a longer review found here

Antoine Fuqua's curiously timed Tears of the Sun is an unpleasant bit of jingoistic bullroar that seeks to redress the Clinton administration's refusal to intervene in the Rwandan genocide by offering up a small band of American special forces soldiers as saviour bwana bravely risking all for a white woman and, incidentally, restoring the son of a slain tribal leader to power. A lot like Schindler's List , for all the devastating scope of human tragedy involved in its story, the film is about the survivors and the white heroes, not the victims.

Martyr complex fully engaged and full speed ahead, Bruce Willis is AK Waters (apparently named after the gun), a stone-faced lieutenant in the Schwarzenegger "Dutch" mode leading a band of highly-trained übermensh on a mission of mercy. The similarities to Predator over the first half of Tears of the Sun are startling (complete with unwilling female charge, token black soldier, pursuit in jungle, and the guerrilla raid of small village); the only real difference is that where John McTiernan's film is a model of the action genre (and, along with Back to the Future, the defining film of the 1980s), Fuqua's Tears of the Sun is an exercise in style over disturbing message.

A propagandist piece for the United States' policy of intervention, the film conspicuously uses an incident in which we didn't intervene (see Steven Silver's brilliant The Last Just Man) as a device to offer some sort of atonement as well as rewrite history. Would that propaganda and revisionism were all the film was invested in; rather, Tears of the Sun sets its sights on racial issues (Token Black Soldier says at one point, "Lt., these Africans, they're my people. You're doing the right thing"), concluding on a pair of speeches offered by a tearful black nurse. The first promises The Bruce that the collective We "will never forget you," the second gushes to noble (and hot) doctor Monica Bellucci that the again collective We "we will always love you." The picture becomes at this point a snow job of the first order: the end-title quote of Edmund Burke's dictum about bad things happening when good folks stand idly by is at that point just atonal overkill (reminding a great deal of The Contender's closing dedication "to our daughters"), and the carefully staged fawning and Indiana Jones native supplication is simply out of place in a movie that takes on a deadly serious topic with occasionally graphic imagery.

The film is noble-savage racist and flag-waving in equal measure--and even misogynistic in not only Belluci's hand-grabbed charge, but also in offering a white priest an on-screen martyrdom as a white nun gobbles helplessly when the scene shifts, fixed eternally in a state of hysteria. Fuqua, an African-American director who's been trying his best to be David Fincher over the course of his sepia-stained career, stages a reasonably compelling village-liberation sequence (and a ridiculously over-hyped finale), but spends the rest of the time indulging in new-millennial action devices like cell phone communications, the GPS chase, and the laptop computer shuffle. Trying to add some excitement to scenes that are basically calls between Willis and commanding officer Tom Skerritt, Fuqua has Skerritt standing on the deck of an aircraft carrier as planes take-off and land behind him--good for reception, probably not so great for the eardrums. As the cavalry rides in at last to evacuate our great white hopes (though the black soldier survives, he's incapacitated and, unlike The Bruce, without the loving ministrations of a ridiculous romantic subplot), the awe that the heretofore desperate refugees massed at the Nigerian border displays for our Yankee whirlybirds doesn't suggest a citizenry hardened from years of modern Civil War, but rather a band of savages genuflecting before a Zippo.-Walter Chaw

The DVD
Columbia Tri-Star's Special Edition DVD release of Tears of the Sun features the strongest video transfer we've seen from the studio in many a moon. The 2.40:1 anamorphic widescreen image is jaw-dropping, really, full of crisp detail that collapses neither during dark exteriors nor in rendering small objects. I would, however, recommend viewing the film in a dim setting, for cinematographer Mauro Fiore (Lost Souls) rarely gives the light obscured by jungle leaves a significant boost. The Dolby Digital 5.1 audio is less impressive, but it doesn't help that I viewed Tears of the Sun in tandem with MGM's Die Another Day (review forthcoming), which boasts of a mix that's particularly earth-shattering in DTS. Though Tears of the Sun's various gunshots and explosions are full, there's a peculiar lack of initiative when it comes to aurally immersing us in the wilds of Africa.

The single-platter SE includes Jeffrey Schwarz's "Journey to Safety: Making Tears of the Sun" (15 mins.), a making-of that gets off to a rocky start thanks to a confused quote from producer Arnold Rifkin: "Tears of the Sun is a metaphor for what's happening today in the world." (Since we're later told that the stuff that happens in the film happens every day in Africa, what's metaphorical?) Inexplicably called "an actor's director," Michael Bay-lite Antoine Fuqua makes probably the most sincere statement of the entire doc (certainly the most heterosexual) when he says he "can't wait to work with Monica Bellucci again." In the segmented "Voices of Africa," eight African citizens share horror stories of being victimized; as their accents run the gamut from thick to indecipherable, one wishes that all of these interviews had been subtitled and not just those conducted in the subject's native tongue. A section of approximately eight deleted scenes sheds light on a backstory prior to the arrival of the SEALS that recalls, at least in terms of mise-en-scène, "Tenko", the British series about a Japanese internment camp for women, and unveils a closing monologue that lazily mimics Martin Luther King, Jr.'s famous speech.

An "Africa Fact Track," a "Writer's Observations" track (in which screenwriters Alex Lasker and Patrick Cirillo wax philosophic until 17 minutes and 13 seconds into Tears of the Sun), and a film-length commentary by a newly excitable Antoine Fuqua (the picture's critical drubbing, as well as dumb studio notes, have him hot under the collar) round out the major extras. Trailers for Tears of the Sun, Anger Management, Bad Boys II, Basic, Black Hawk Down, Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle, Hollywood Homicide, Radio (starring Cuba Gooding, Jr. in Bubba Gump choppers, I never thought I'd live to see what appears to be an austere remake of The Waterboy), and S.W.A.T. finish off the platter.-Bill Chambers

© Film Freak Central; filmfreakcentral.net. This review may not be reprinted, in whole or in part, without the express consent of its author.

Tears of the Sun cover
Buy at Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices

DVD GRADES:
Image A+
Sound A-
Extras B

DVD VITALS:
RunningTime
121 minutes
MPAA
R
AspectRatio(s)
2.40:1 ONLY, 16x9-enhanced

Languages
English DD 5.1,
French DD 5.1,
French Stereo
CC

Yes
Subtitles
English, French
DVD-9
Region One
Columbia Tri-Star


Buy the TEARS OF THE SUN poster at Moviegoods (click on image)

Get it at Amazon!
TEARS OF THE SUN
Original Motion Picture Soundtrack CD
Buy at Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada

What's coming out on DVD? Check the release calendar

AUTEUR'S CORNER

Published: June 2, 2003