Search Film Freak Central Web search

powered by FreeFind

Logo: FFC does Billy Wilder on DVD
Join "Film Freak Central"'s mailing list
(receive update alerts Thursdays bi-weekly)
Enter your name and email address:
Name:
Email:
Subscribe Unsubscribe

Billy Wilder Collection cover

THE BILLY WILDER DVD COLLECTION
Buy At Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices
featuring Some Like It Hot, The Apartment, One, Two, Three, Irma La Douce, Kiss Me, Stupid, The Fortune Cookie, The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes, Avanti!

also by Billy Wilder:
Sunset Blvd., The Seven Year Itch

ONE, TWO, THREE (1961)
starring James Cagney, Horst Buccholz, Pamela Tiffin, Arlene Francis
screenplay by Billy Wilder & I.A.L. Diamond, based on the play by Ferenc Molnar

One, Two, Three cover
Buy At Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices
Ingeborg (Lilo Pulver), MacNamara's luscious blonde secretary: "It's 'froy-line,' with an umlaut."
MacNamara (James Cagney): "I'll say!"

A hilarious free-for-all graced with mad genius, One, Two, Three makes them Keystone Cops look like slowpokes. Every time I watch it, I find myself perched on the edge of my seat, hoping that the film's fever pitch doesn't give the ever-inflamed James Cagney a heart attack--an illogically primal reaction that restores whatever immediacy the ravages of time have stolen from this precursor to Dr. Strangelove. Cagney stars as C.R. MacNamara, a Coca-Cola company man stationed in West Germany just after the Berlin Wall went up, willing to do whatever it takes to stay abroad for fear of relocation to the head office in Atlanta ("Siberia with mint juleps").

Pierre (Jacques Chevalier), a handsome pilot begging MacNamara's wife for assistance: "Madam, I appeal to you as a woman!"
Mrs. MacNamara (Arlene Francis): "As a matter of fact you do."

When the boss calls to say he's shipping out his promiscuous seventeen-year-old daughter Scarlett (Pamela Tiffin) to him for the summer, MacNamara cancels a long-overdue family vacation to babysit her--and she chews so quickly through his leash that before he knows it, Scarlett is Mrs. Otto Ludwig Piffl, the wife of a die-hard communist (Horst Buchholz, who at first seems to be spoofing Billy Wilder (the cap, the petulance), is much better cast here than as a Mexican in The Magnificent Seven). With Scarlett's marriage coinciding with the due arrival of her parents, MacNamara, while simultaneously brokering a deal to get a Coca-Cola plant in Russia, devises a plan to have Otto captured by the secret police (who wind up torturing Otto by subjecting him to "Itsy Bitsy Teenie Weenie Yellow Polka-Dot Bikini" ad nauseam; for all of Wilder's discernible hatred of rock 'n' roll, One, Two, Three's pop-cultural references, too numerous to catalogue here, betray a sensitivity to the zeitgeist that paints Tarantino as the curmudgeon) that's easy as one, two, three, but there's more to the situation than is visible on the surface, and a cuckoo clock--which plays, appropriately (if prosaically), "Yankee Doodle Went to Town" when it chimes--counts down the hours MacNamara has left to straighten things out.

MacNamara: "I'm not gonna let that communist kook ruin somebody's life!"
Mrs. MacNamara: "But she loves him!"
MacNamara: "Not hers, mine!"

A dyed-in-the-wool Republican off-camera, Cagney works himself into a genuine lather as a monger of the American dream in One, Two, Three, the undercurrent of authentic hostility to his performance--Cagney spends the entire film crushing proverbial grapefruits in people's faces until literally threatening to repeat that seminal moment from The Public Enemy--probably directed at the eminently-quotable Wilder/I.A.L. Diamond screenplay (adapted from a play by Hungarian Ferenc Molnar), which refuses to join a team: the Yankees and Russkies are portrayed as commensurate buffoons. The term "tour-de-force" should be reserved for lesser work: Cagney transforms a screwball farce into a fireball farce, and you can sense the other actors a little waylaid by his comedic ferocity. It's only in the film's final moments that its satire is pitched so as to threaten agenda, perhaps Cagney's ultimate reason for accepting what would be his last leading role; One, Two, Three's ending is the triumph of Western values, and while the antihero's victory is preferable in its sadistic wish-fulfilment to the mawkishness of The Fortune Cookie's conclusion (wherein the MacNamara-esque Walter Matthau character is duly punished), it's impossible to shake the chill one gets from seeing a sort of flipside to the Red Scare coin Don Siegel played (or, at least, wanted to play before the studio interfered) in Invasion of the Body Snatchers. You'll be asking yourself throughout how a picture this subversive got bankrolled, but there's no mystery left at the curtain call.

MacNamara: "Can't we discuss our problems without bringing up rival beverages?"

The best-looking disc in MGM's "Billy Wilder DVD Collection" and the second-most handsome of the Wilder titles available on the format thus far (edged-out by Sunset Blvd.), One, Two, Three preserves Daniel L. Fapp's Oscar-nominated cinematography with tremendous clarity of detail and contrast. (Sadly, Fapp received the film's only Academy nod.) Ignore the pan-and-scan side of the disc in favour of the 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer; I just wish I knew why MGM keeps replacing original logos with the '90s-era growling Leo: it makes no sense to introduce a b&w movie with a splash of colour, for starters. Source material is in excellent condition with the exception of irregular blotches that could be water damage. (It's doubtful the immersed viewer will notice them, anyhow.) The 2.0 mono soundtrack potently reproduces Wilder's sixties composer André Previn's riffs on Richard Wagner and Aram Khachaturyan, and Cagney's voice lacks the shrill quality one anticipates from previous viewings. One, Two, Three's theatrical trailer rounds out the disc--I sure do miss the edifying liner notes inserts of MGM's Woody Allen DVDs. ***1/2 (out of four) | Image: A, Sound: B+ | English Mono, French Mono, Spanish Mono | CC | English, French, Spanish Subtitles | DVD-10 | 109 minutes -Bill Chambers

IRMA LA DOUCE (1963)
starring Jack Lemmon, Shirley MacLaine, Lou Jacobi, Bruce Yarnell
screenplay by Billy Wilder and I.A.L. Diamond

Irma La Douce cover
Buy At Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices
Until Irma La Douce (1963), movie prostitutes were of the touch-me-not variety, the Holly Golightly breed who invariably paid the (sometimes ultimate) price for the oldest profession--they were never happy, bright, and chirpily philosophical. The casting of Shirley MacLaine as the titular poule makes sense in that just three years after Billy Wilder's The Apartment, it brought her and Jack Lemmon back together as lovers divided by sordid circumstance (and cohabiting an apartment again, as it happens), but Wilder's wish to cast Marilyn Monroe instead would have been the better choice. She is, after all, far less burdened by the weight of intelligence and melancholy than MacLaine (or, at least, her screen persona is)--qualities that serve MacLaine extremely well in the darkly-hued The Apartment, and much less so in what is literally a gauzy Technicolor slapstick musical sans song-and-dance numbers. Still, what works about Irma La Douce is the sprightliness of the interplay between the elfin Irma and her arguably more elfin beau/benefactor Nestor (Lemmon), both finding in Wilder the sort of director who understood the quality of the "attractive goons, winsome losers, and sympathetic heels" Ethan Mordden described as comprising the prototypical Wilder hero. And it is that marriage of paradoxes, particularly the one which finds MacLaine cast as the bimbo, that gives Irma La Douce the kind of dark, self-reflexive undercurrent that defined the unrest of '60s cinema.

So Irma the Sweet and her pimp Hippolyte (Bruce Yarnell, whose checked suit's moiré problems the DVD never solves) have a falling out after recently-fired gendarme Nestor bests Hippolyte in a drunken brawl. In need of a new "mec," Irma vows her allegiance to Nestor, who in turn disguises himself as wealthy Lord X so that his beloved need not sell her body to the night. Described by Wilder as the story of a man jealous of himself, Irma mistakes Nestor's graveyard shifts at the local butcher and fish market for indiscretions, and conspires to run away with Lord X, leading to a murder, a prison term, and the unlikeliest of contrivances, a Catholic wedding that takes less than three hours.

The prescribed happy ending of Irma La Douce comes with a metaphysical twist that undermines at once the picture's knowledge of itself as theatre and underscores the elasticity of cinema in creating illusion--the kind of directorial megalomania generally associated with Alfred Hitchcock. An inopportune birth is preceded by the Falstaff character Moustache (Lou Jacobi, in a role earmarked for the ailing Charles Laughton) hilariously motioning for the priest performing a wedding to speed it up a little in what could sub for a director's cameo, both events attended by the entire company in a way that is merely puzzling before becoming invasive. The idea of the viewer as voyeur--from the crowd gathered around the closed door behind which Irma is experiencing labour to the closing shots where a door is thrown open and we, the audience, play the invading throng--is explored with a sort of sugar-coated viciousness by Wilder here, pinging off the sleazy travelogue carnival façades of his previous film, One, Two, Three. Irma and Nestor's first night together is preceded by Nestor blocking off the window's to Irma's room and even asking Irma to don a blindfold while we sit amused by his humiliation at having to strip before his heart's desire. Irma herself strips several times, each seen illicitly in a mirror, Wilder inviting us to participate in the sort of leer that Hitchcock's Psycho (the quintessential sixties picture) introduced to our cinematic vocabulary: Wilder the pimp, Irma the whore, and we the John.

Ostensibly a light-hearted farce of the Indiscreet variety, the picture has moments of hilarity; with Lemmon at the peak of his lovable loser, cross-dressing game, the picture is more obviously a companion to Some Like it Hot than The Apartment. A montage of Nestor at work is perversely cheerful, laying André Previn's jaunty, Oscar-winning score over scenes of Nestor, soaked in blood, carrying carcasses around with Wilder comparing his hero's head first to a severed boar's, then to a head of cabbage. Nothing about Irma La Douce can be taken at face value, however, with Wilder ever caustic and unsympathetic as the film itself moves along with a blithe airiness. The interest of the director's films can usually be defined in terms of that discomfort: the tension between a film in a familiar genre and a director who delights in delivering a draught of acid as chaser. The hyper-reality of the film is brought to eye-catching life in MGM's release of Irma La Douce, offered in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio in a 16:9 anamorphic video transfer that only really fails in the abovementioned moiré problems with Hippolyte's suit and, in chapter 11, during a brief shot of a similarly-patterned garage door outside Irma's hotel. A couple moments of edge enhancement don't distract from the fact that this film, with its expansive sets and mattes, deserves to be seen in its widescreen incarnation. The original English mono track is absolutely adequate, as spare and impressive/unimpressive as the disc's sole special feature: a long trailer that includes an animated film synopsis. ***1/2 (out of four) | Image: A, Sound: B | English Mono, French Mono, Spanish Mono | CC | French, Spanish Subtitles | DVD-9 | 143 minutes -Walter Chaw

top


THE FORTUNE COOKIE (1966)
starring Jack Lemmon, Walter Matthau, Ron Rich, Judi West
screenplay by Billy Wilder and I.A.L. Diamond

The Fortune Cookie cover
Buy At Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices
The Fortune Cookie was an attempt on Billy Wilder and I.A.L. Diamond's part to summon up the salad days of six years previous, when their one-two punch of Some Like It Hot and The Apartment hit pay dirt. (Imagine Steven Spielberg's 1993, with its back-to-back releases of Jurassic Park and Schindler's List, and you'll have some idea of the position that Wilder and Diamond were in following The Apartment's Oscar glory.) More to the point, it was an act of redemption for the roundly lambasted Kiss Me, Stupid, and like most movie art seeking atonement from the masses, it so slavishly recapitulates a past success that audiences still aren't getting what they want, only what they've had. A homoerotic redux of The Apartment, with Jack Lemmon reassuming the role of the weak-willed schlub and a black man filling in for Shirley MacLaine (although these character ascriptions prove interchangeable), The Fortune Cookie does nothing so well as make you wish you were watching The Apartment instead.

Lemmon plays Harry Hinkle (an alliterative name like his Apartment designation "Bud" Baxter), a CBS cameraman knocked unconscious on the football field by Cleveland Brown "Boom Boom" Jackson (Ron Rich). Regaining consciousness in a Catholic hospital, Hinkle finds out he has suffered a mild concussion, but brother-in-law Willie Gingrich (Walter Matthau, who won a Best Supporting Actor Academy Award for his droll but unspectacular turn here, I suspect to honour the heart attack he survived halfway through the shoot), an ambulance-chasing lawyer called "Whiplash" behind his back, persuades Hinkle, by promising a reunion with his ex-wife (Judi West), to exaggerate the severity of the injuries sustained for the sake of bilking the insurance company. As in The Apartment, we're trapped in Lemmon's shabby digs for the majority of the piece, only this time, it's he who's nursed back to "health" by the MacLaine surrogate: Boom Boom is so wracked with guilt that he enslaves himself to the falsely wheelchair-bound Hinkle. Wilder biographer Cameron Crowe's observation that "race is not an issue" in The Fortune Cookie is deluded even for the director of Almost Famous; what does a film made during the peak of the civil rights movement in which an affluent African-American male instinctively yokes himself to a white master (and Hinkle soaks up every bit of the attention) walk if not a political tightrope?

Then again, their relationship is less offensive than stale, a set-up for object lessons in scruples. And it ultimately doesn't resonate like The Apartment's central pairing because Hinkle and Boom Boom aren't kindred spirits à la C.C. Baxter and Fran Kubelik--you don't want Boom Boom to tell Hinkle to "shut up and deal," you just want both of them to shut up. (Boom Boom's too saintly for words, anyway.) Nevertheless, no Wilder film is meritless: "The Snake Pit" segment of The Fortune Cookie sees a vicious German scientist telling an apocryphal story about outmoded claims-investigation tactics that captures some of the magic of the hilarious anecdotes the Austrian Wilder used to share at awards shows; Andre Previn's score finds a catchy, Mancini-esque bounce; and the cinematography, by Joseph La Shelle in his fourth and final collaboration with Wilder, is light years more eye-catching than that of any modern comedy. MGM drops the "Vintage Classics" banner for their DVD reissue of The Fortune Cookie, available individually or as part of the "Billy Wilder Collection". The 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer is not going to blow anybody's socks off, but one becomes accustomed to the bleariness and shimmer artifacts of the black-and-white image. The 2.0 mono sound is abundantly clear and hiss-free. The sole extra is the original theatrical trailer.** (out of four) | Image: C+, Sound: B | English Mono, French Mono | CC | French, Spanish Subtitles | DVD-9 | 126 minutes -Bill Chambers

top


THE PRIVATE LIFE OF SHERLOCK HOLMES (1970)
starring Robert Stephens, Colin Blakely, Genevieve Page, Christopher Lee
screenplay by Billy Wilder and I.A.L. Diamond

The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes cover
Buy At Amazon USA
Buy at Amazon Canada
or Compare Prices
Billy Wilder. Sherlock Holmes. A mismatch of flavours the thought of which doesn't so much turn your stomach as lead to speculation, and the taste of which is soured only by a foreknowledge of missed opportunities. The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes was to be Wilder's roadshow movie, his intermission film--a "symphony in four parts," as he called it, that would run longer than three hours excluding the break in the middle. The script, written by Wilder and mainstay collaborator I.A.L. Diamond over a period of twelve years as a blend of homage to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and adaptation of the same, was shot in its entirety, but at some point during post-production, Wilder took off to prep another project, and two of the four "movements" plus a present-day prologue and subheadings (each story passage had its own introductory title card) were lifted out of the film in answer to the common test-screening complaint that it was "too episodic" (well, duh), with only one of the movements preserved (somewhat perfunctorily, because it had nice imagery of an ocean liner) for possible inclusion in a TV version that never materialized. It's important to note that editor Ernest Walter and producer Walter Mirisch liquidated parts of The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes with Wilder's blessing, though Wilder seems to have regretted the decision in his late-life conversations with Cameron Crowe.

What remains is a perfectly-cast film that doesn't quite hold up its end of the bargain made by an opening voiceover that states we're about to see a potentially unflattering portrait of Holmes (Robert Stephens) courtesy anecdotes Dr. Watson (Colin Blakely) hadn't the wherewithal to publish in Strand Magazine when his super-sleuth partner was alive. Though the picture is ultimately too prosaic to be confidential, The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes might have been the first Holmes interpretation for the screen since 1939's The Hound of the Baskervilles to acknowledge the detective's taste for a seven-percent solution of cocaine. The film feels like a work in progress, even if its bittersweet bookends give off a convincing illusion of completeness and Watson challenges Holmes' claims to heterosexuality often enough to add a sardonic humour typical of Wilder that consolidates the title character's dalliance--which wasn't built to support the picture, as became expected of it--with Madame Valladon (Genevieve Page), the aristocratic femme fatale whose husband has vanished, with the rest of the proceedings. That alliance of comedy and drama which proved so pivotal to the success of Wilder's The Apartment keeps The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes afloat through the sinking realization that we are watching the I'll Do Anything of its generation (and I would argue that I'll Do Anything's director James L. Brooks, much more than Brooks' protégé Crowe, is the modern Wilder), a feature-length retraction of romantic ambition too poignant in its own right to discount.

MGM offers The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes on DVD individually or as part of the 8-disc (not 9, as announced--Witness for the Prosecution was mysteriously dropped) "Billy Wilder Collection", and granted the studio's stabs at reconstruction and their decision to at long last present the film for home viewing in its original aspect ratio therein, this is an essential platter. The 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen transfer bears a seventies mien in its low-contrast mistiness, and the source print, though fresh-looking, is not pristine, but the restored compositions contribute a sense of scale and improve the film's humour, particularly a sight gag involving Watson dancing in a chorus line that was overreliant on our imagination in pan-and-scan. While the 2.0 mono soundtrack is inoffensive, nothing more or less, the extra features provoke unbridled enthusiasm. For starters, there is "Christopher Lee: Mr. Holmes, Mr. Wilder", a 15-minute featurette that doesn't get around to the Wilder portion of the conversation until the 9-minute mark, but nonetheless imparts an impressive amount of Holmes arcana in a short period. (Lee has thrice played Holmes on-screen and appears as Sherlock's "smarter" brother Mycroft in The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes.) His posture occasionally defensive, Lee barks, "People who say that I'm typecast shouldn't be in the business," referring to having logged so much time outside the gothic horror genre.

Meanwhile, the "Interview with Ernest Walter" (29 mins.) is bound to be a difficult watch for some film fans, as Walter effortlessly--with the Diamond/Wilder screenplay on his lap--itemizes his alterations to the The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes' intended structure, and the nature of the piece (Walter addressing an ancient video camera impersonally mounted on a tripod) lends it a strangely confessional quality not unlike the recent Blind Spot: Hitler's Secretary. Nevertheless, this is an invaluable historical document (especially given Wilder's notorious stinginess with the details of the film's bowdlerization) that pre-emptively answers questions raised by the section of "deleted scenes" regarding their context and how they may have impacted the material in the final film. MGM's search for the lost footage turned up only the aforementioned sequence set aside for television ("The Dreadful Business of the Naked Honeymooners" (12 mins.)), albeit without a dialogue track (necessitating subtitles) and with nudity blurred out. The other omissions--the prologue (9 mins.), "The Curious Case of the Upside-Down Room" (25 mins.), and "The Adventures of the Dumbfounded Detective" (4 mins.)--are patchworks of script pages and production photos that push Holmes closer still towards the archetypally paper-tigerish Wilder hero. A backstage gallery 47 slides strong (a few of which are inexplicably cartoons) and the film's theatrical trailer round out The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes DVD.*** (out of four) | Image: B+, Sound: B, Extras: A | English Mono | CC | English, French, Spanish Subtitles | DVD-9 | 125 minutes -Bill Chambers


© Film Freak Central; filmfreakcentral.net. This review may not be reprinted, in whole or in part, without the express consent of its author.